When facing mental health issues and life difficulties, people often rely solely on themselves. The situation slightly improves when individuals seek help and support from loved ones. However, due to the stigma surrounding professional mental health assistance, many hesitate to approach mental health professionals. 

This hesitation is further compounded by a lack of information about which professional to consult for specific challenges. Delaying help-seeking can worsen symptoms and, ultimately, lead to longer treatment. Therefore, this article aims to explain the similarities and differences between psychologists, psychiatrists, and psychotherapists, and clarify which professional may be most beneficial under different circumstances. While the roles of mental health professionals overlap significantly, each has its unique features.

Psychiatrist

Psychiatrists are medical doctors who, after completing medical school, specialize in psychiatry – a branch of medicine that deals with the study, diagnosis, and treatment of mental illnesses¹. They use a medical model focused primarily on the physical aspects of mental illnesses, possessing detailed knowledge of brain anatomy, its functions, and physiological processes in humans. Psychiatrists understand the biological causes of mental disorders and the effects of various medications on different organ systems, allowing them to assess what treatment might be beneficial for an individual. They are also trained to recognize physical illnesses or dysfunctions that may produce similar symptoms, recommending additional tests to determine whether such a cause might exist. Psychiatrists can diagnose mental disorders and prescribe medication for treatment.

In practice, psychiatrists primarily treat mental health issues using medications and manage mental illnesses and disorders, focusing on individuals with more enduring mental health challenges. Patients under psychiatric care typically attend check-ups every few months. During these appointments, the psychiatrist monitors the effectiveness of prescribed medication, discussing current symptoms, their changes, and how the patient tolerates the medication. Based on this information, they recommend further treatment. Psychiatric consultations are usually brief, lasting 15–20 minutes, and are not intended for counseling or psychotherapy but rather for monitoring medication effects.

Psychiatrists usually work in hospitals or private clinics. In hospitals, they often collaborate with psychologists and other professionals to provide comprehensive care and facilitate holistic recovery. Many psychiatrists pursue additional education in specific psychotherapeutic approaches, allowing them to act as psychotherapists and provide psychological counseling and psychotherapy.

Psychologist

Psychologists complete a degree in psychology, gaining knowledge about mental processes and human behavior in general. Psychology applies to various areas of life, so psychologists can work in schools, companies, industries, forensics, sports, etc., without necessarily dealing with mental health issues or individual counseling. However, they do learn about the symptoms and diagnosis of mental health difficulties during their studies. The field of psychology that deals with mental health issues, their diagnosis, and treatment is known as clinical psycho

Psychologists view mental health issues through a biopsychosocial model, which includes biological, psychological, and social factors as potential causes. They use various psychological techniques (primarily conversation-based) and knowledge acquired during their studies and additional training to treat these issues. Psychologists cannot prescribe medication as they are not medical doctors.

A key skill and tool of psychologists is psychological testing – a set of methods to assess a person’s traits, abilities, and skills, and sometimes their perceptions, thoughts, and behaviors. Psychological testing cannot be performed by psychiatrists or psychotherapists (unless they are also psychologists)². Testing is not always aimed at identifying mental health issues; for instance, it is often used in employee selection processes to evaluate candidates’ personality traits and potential fit within a company. Psychologists working in hospitals collaborate with psychiatrists by administering and interpreting psychological questionnaires and tests, aiding psychiatrists in diagnosis and improving patient care³.

Psychotherapist

A psychotherapist is someone who has completed (typically a five-year) training in a specific psychotherapeutic approach. The most common and widely practiced approaches include cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), gestalt therapy, psychoanalysis, analytical psychotherapy, transactional analysis, body-oriented psychotherapy, schema therapy, and others⁴. These approaches differ in theoretical framework and methods but share the goal of helping clients gain deeper self-awareness and change thought, behavior, and emotional patterns that cause distress. Psychotherapists are often psychologists, but individuals from other professions – such as psychiatrists, social workers, educational rehabilitators, or social pedagogues – can also become psychotherapists after completing a preparatory course in psychotherapy, which equips them with essential psychological knowledge⁴.

Psychotherapists provide psychological counseling and psychotherapy. Counseling offers short-term support for managing current life challenges, adapting to changes, or dealing with temporary psychological difficulties, while psychotherapy is a longer process aimed at achieving personality changes or managing symptoms of mental disorders or illnesses. Counseling and psychotherapy sessions typically last 45–60 minutes and are held weekly. The number of sessions required depends on the specific issue the client is facing. For instance, treating a phobia may require just 1–5 sessions. In practice, the line between counseling and psychotherapy can blur, as clients may initially seek help for a specific life challenge but continue therapy to work on other aspects of themselves. Work with a psychotherapist generally lasts longer than with a psychiatrist, as psychotherapy involves exploring emotions, relationships, identity, motivation, and more.

Whom to Consult?

It’s important to emphasize that support from mental health professionals is not exclusively for individuals with mental disorders or illnesses. It can also benefit those experiencing temporary psychological difficulties or even those without any issues who simply wish to work on themselves and become a more satisfied and resilient version of themselves. Ultimately, it’s more important to seek help when needed than to choose the “correct” professional – mental health professionals can recognize when and if they need to refer you to someone else.

Choosing the best form of support for an individual can be challenging, as there’s no universal solution. Some individuals may not improve with medication until they start psychotherapy, while others may not achieve desired changes with therapy but do so with medication. In practice, the treatment of mental disorders and illnesses is most effective when it combines medication and psychotherapy. For individuals without a diagnosed disorder or illness, psychotherapy alone can often lead to improvement. For conditions with a strong biological basis, such as schizophrenia, bipolar affective disorder, and often depression, medication is often necessary, as individuals may lack the capacity to participate effectively in therapy without it. Medications are prescribed for significant functional difficulties and/or pronounced physical symptoms, but the decision to take them ultimately rests with you. Psychiatrists often recommend psychotherapy alongside medication, while psychotherapists may suggest consulting a psychiatrist for medication evaluation or obtaining an official diagnosis, which might be needed for legal or other purposes.

Leave a Comment